When choosing the right power switch, it’s essential to match the device to your specific needs. MOSFETs excel at fast switching in low-voltage applications, while IGBTs are better suited for handling high voltages and large currents, though they switch more slowly. Understanding the main differences between IGBTs and MOSFETs is crucial in power electronics, especially in applications like motor drives and power supplies. Here are some current market trends:
| Device Type | Market Share | Main Use |
|---|---|---|
| IGBT | Over 55% | EV inverters, motor drives |
| MOSFET | High in low/medium voltage | Consumer electronics, power supplies |
Ultimately, choosing the right power switch depends on your voltage, current, and switching speed requirements.
Key Takeaways
-
Pick MOSFETs for quick switching and lower voltage circuits. You get good efficiency and less heat with them.
-
Use IGBTs for high voltage and high current jobs. They are better when you need strong power and reliability, not speed.
-
MOSFETs switch faster than IGBTs. This makes them great for high-frequency power supplies and converters.
-
IGBTs can handle heat better. They work well in large machines, electric cars, and big motor drives.
-
Always think about your project’s voltage, current, and speed. Also look at efficiency, cooling, and cost to choose the best power switch.
Main Differences Between IGBTs and MOSFETs
Voltage and Current Range
When you look at these devices, you see they each have their own strengths. MOSFETs are best for low or medium voltage jobs. They usually work from 20V up to 1000V. They handle low or medium current, so they fit well in things like power supplies and electronics at home. IGBTs are made for much higher voltage and current. You will find IGBTs in circuits that need 600V to 6500V. They can handle currents from 100A to 3600A. This makes IGBTs great for big jobs, like running motors in factories or large inverters.
| Device Type | Typical Voltage Range | Typical Current Range |
|---|---|---|
| MOSFET | 20V to 1000V | Low to moderate current applications |
| IGBT | 600V to 6500V | 100A to 3600A (high current) |
Pick a MOSFET if your circuit needs to switch fast at lower voltages. If you need to control high voltage and big currents, an IGBT is more reliable and works better.
Switching Speed
Switching speed is a big difference between IGBTs and MOSFETs. MOSFETs can switch on and off very fast. They use only electrons to work, so they are quick. This makes MOSFETs good for high-frequency circuits, like switching power supplies and DC-DC converters. You can use MOSFETs at hundreds of kilohertz or even more. This helps make smaller and more efficient circuits.
IGBTs switch slower because they use both electrons and holes. Their switching speed is usually below 20 kHz, but some special ones can go higher. Most of the time, you use IGBTs where switching speed is not as important as handling high voltage and current. For example, IGBTs are used in electric cars and big machines, where power and reliability matter more than speed.
Tip: If your project needs fast switching and low losses, MOSFETs are better. For high-power circuits that do not need fast switching, IGBTs are more efficient and reliable.
| Characteristic | IGBT | MOSFET |
|---|---|---|
| Switching Speed | Slower, suitable for low-frequency | Faster, suitable for high-frequency |
| Suitable Frequency | Typically up to 20-50 kHz | Can reach hundreds of kHz or higher |
Efficiency
Efficiency is important when picking between these two devices. MOSFETs have low resistance when on, so they waste less energy as heat at low voltages and currents. They also lose less energy when switching, so they are very efficient in high-frequency, low-power circuits. But if the current gets high, MOSFETs lose efficiency because they start to waste more energy.
IGBTs do better with high current and high voltage. They lose less energy as heat at high power, so they are good for big jobs. IGBTs can also handle more heat without breaking. This makes them a good pick for motor drives and other high-power uses. But IGBTs lose more energy when switching, especially at high speeds, so they are not as efficient in fast-switching circuits.
| Characteristic | MOSFETs | IGBTs |
|---|---|---|
| Conduction Loss | Lower at low current/voltage | Lower at high current/voltage |
| Switching Loss | Low switching losses, fast switching | Higher switching losses, slower switching |
| Efficiency | High at low power/high frequency | High at high power/low frequency |
| Thermal Performance | Needs heat sinks at high power | Better thermal stability |
Look for low energy loss and high efficiency in your design. MOSFETs are best for low-power, high-frequency circuits. IGBTs are better for high-power, low-frequency circuits.
Application Scenarios
You can find MOSFETs and IGBTs in many power electronics jobs. MOSFETs are used in circuits that need fast switching and low voltage. These include switching power supplies, DC-DC converters, and audio amplifiers. They are good for these uses because they switch fast and waste little energy.
IGBTs are best for high-power and high-voltage jobs. You will see IGBTs in electric cars, big motor drives, large inverters, and renewable energy systems. They can handle high current and voltage and work well in tough places.
| Aspect | MOSFET Applications and Characteristics | IGBT Applications and Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Handling | Efficient at lower voltages | Better suited for higher voltage applications |
| Switching Speed | Fast switching, ideal for quick response applications | Slower switching speed compared to MOSFETs |
| Power Efficiency | High efficiency at low power levels | More efficient in high-power applications |
| Thermal Management | Generates less heat, better for low-voltage systems | Superior thermal management, suitable for high-power systems |
| Typical Applications | Power supplies, amplifiers, low to moderate power inverters, UPS systems | Industrial machinery, electric vehicles, large-scale power supplies, high-power inverters |
When you choose between these devices, think about what your project needs. Look at voltage, current, switching speed, and efficiency. MOSFETs are good for fast switching and low energy loss in small, high-frequency circuits. IGBTs give you more efficiency and reliability in big, high-power systems.
MOSFET Overview
What is a MOSFET
A MOSFET is a special kind of transistor. It helps control electricity in a circuit. There are three main parts: gate, source, and drain. The gate sits on an oxide layer above silicon. When you put voltage on the gate, it makes an electric field. This field creates a path for current to flow. The current moves from the source to the drain. You can turn the current on or off by changing the gate voltage. Most power MOSFETs use a vertical design. This helps them handle high voltages and currents. The silicon layer’s thickness sets the voltage rating. The channel’s width controls how much current can flow. Many MOSFETs use DMOS technology. This makes them strong and reliable for power electronics.
Advantages
MOSFETs have many good points, especially in low-voltage and fast circuits. They are controlled by voltage, not current. You do not need much current to turn them on or off. Their low on-resistance means less energy is lost as heat. This keeps your circuits working well. MOSFETs switch on and off very quickly. This is great for pulse-width modulation and other fast jobs. You can connect several MOSFETs together to handle more current. This is possible because of their positive temperature coefficient. Lately, SiC MOSFETs have become popular. These switch even faster and handle higher voltages than regular silicon types. They also work well in hot places, so they are good for tough jobs.
| Parameter | MOSFET Advantage |
|---|---|
| Control Type | Voltage-controlled device |
| On-Resistance (Rds-on) | Low (mΩ range) |
| Switching Speed | Very fast, ideal for high-frequency use |
| Paralleling Capability | Easy, improves current handling |
Disadvantages
MOSFETs are great, but they have some limits. Power MOSFETs have a big gate charge and input capacitance. You need a strong gate driver to switch them fast, especially in big circuits. P-channel MOSFETs have higher on-resistance and lower current ability. This makes them less useful for large jobs. N-channel MOSFETs need a higher gate voltage for high-side switching. This can make your circuit harder to design. MOSFETs do not handle very high voltages as well as IGBTs. They can be damaged by static electricity because their gate is sensitive. SiC MOSFETs cost more than regular silicon ones. But they work better in tough jobs.
Note: If you use MOSFETs in high-power or high-voltage circuits, make sure your gate driver is strong enough. Also, protect the gate from static electricity.
-
Not as good at handling high voltage as IGBTs
-
Can be damaged by static electricity
-
Cost more, especially SiC MOSFETs
-
High-side switching needs a complex gate drive
Best Uses
You can find MOSFETs in lots of modern electronics. They work well in power amplifiers for audio systems. In cars, they help control ignition and power in electric vehicles. MOSFETs are important in switching power supplies, DC-DC converters, and motor controllers. Their fast switching and low on-resistance make them perfect for these uses. SiC MOSFETs are now used in solar inverters, electric vehicle chargers, and high-efficiency power supplies. These devices help make circuits smaller, cooler, and more efficient. You can also use MOSFETs in LED lights, voltage regulators, and battery management systems.
-
Power amplifiers and audio systems
-
Automotive electronics and electric vehicles
-
Switching power supplies and DC-DC converters
-
Motor control and PWM circuits
-
Solar inverters and high-efficiency power supplies (using SiC MOSFETs)
-
LED lighting and voltage regulation
IGBT Overview
What is an IGBT
An insulated gate bipolar transistor helps control lots of power. It mixes the good parts of a MOSFET and a BJT. The IGBT has four layers and three terminals. These are called gate, collector, and emitter. The gate sits on an insulated layer. This lets you use voltage to control the device. When you put voltage on the gate, current can flow. The current moves from the collector to the emitter. The IGBT works like a switch for high power.
| Aspect | Description |
|---|---|
| Basic Structure | IGBT has four layers and three PN junctions. It has three terminals: Gate (G), Collector (C), and Emitter (E). The gate is insulated by silicon dioxide. It controls the device by making a channel that conducts electricity. |
| Construction Details | The collector connects to the P+ layer. An N- drift region sits above it. P regions are made on the N- layer. N+ regions are added over the P region. The emitter connects to the N+ region. The gate is insulated and placed above the P region. |
| Equivalent Structure | It mixes an N-channel MOSFET input and a PNP BJT output. This is like a Darlington setup. It shows the hybrid nature of IGBT. |
| Operating Principle | When you put positive voltage on the gate, an N-channel forms under the gate oxide. This lets electrons move from the emitter to the drift region. At the same time, holes go from the P+ collector into the drift region. This makes it easier for current to flow from collector to emitter. If you remove the gate voltage, the device turns off. |
| Key Features | It is controlled by voltage. It has high input impedance from the MOSFET. It can handle lots of current from the BJT. |
Advantages
Silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors have many good points. They handle high voltages and big currents easily. You see them in HVDC power transmission. They can manage currents over 2,000 amps. They work well in power grids. They help keep voltage steady and stop flicker. Medium-voltage motor drives use IGBTs for their reliability. They also have a modular design. New silicon IGBTs use better structures. These lower voltage drop and switching losses. You get better efficiency and longer life.
-
Low voltage drop when on, so less energy and heat are lost.
-
Fast switching speeds, good for high-frequency jobs.
-
Very reliable and last a long time.
-
Can handle high voltage, great for tough power systems.
-
Good thermal stability, so they stay cool and last longer.
-
Small size and high power density, saving space in your system.
Tip: Silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors keep low resistance even at high voltages and currents. This makes them great for electric trains, vehicles, and induction cookers.
Disadvantages
You should know the limits of silicon IGBTs before using them. They switch slower than MOSFETs. If you need very fast switching, you may get more heat and less efficiency. IGBTs can get too hot in high-power jobs. This can cause reliability problems. Sometimes, they get stuck in the "on" state if there is a fault. Silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors cost more than some other switches.
-
Slower switching speed than MOSFETs.
-
More heat at high switching frequencies.
-
Higher cost than some alternatives.
-
Rare latching problem under fault conditions.
Silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors work best in low-frequency jobs, up to 20 kHz. If you need fast switching, you may want to use a MOSFET instead.
Best Uses
IGBTs are used in many high-power and industrial systems. They are important in electric vehicles, solar inverters, and wind turbines. You also find them in motor drives for robots and factory machines. Uninterruptible power supplies in hospitals and data centers use silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors for backup power. Trains and metro systems use IGBTs for strong and steady traction.
| Use Case Category | Specific Applications | Key Benefits and Features |
|---|---|---|
| Electric Vehicles (EVs) | Powertrains, battery management, AC-DC power supplies, and regenerative braking | High efficiency, precise switching, strong voltage/current ratings |
| Renewable Energy | Solar inverters, wind turbine converters, DC conversion systems | Can switch high voltage, saves energy |
| Industrial Automation | Motor control in robotics, variable frequency drives (VFDs) | Low switching losses, high efficiency |
| Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) | Backup power and voltage regulation in data centers and hospitals | Reliable operation, saves energy |
| Railway and Transportation | High-power traction systems for electric trains and metro rail systems | Stable, reliable control, handles lots of power |
You can also use silicon insulated gate bipolar transistors in battery units and thermal management in electric vehicles. They help control power flow and keep batteries safe. Their strong performance and reliability make them a smart choice for many high-power jobs.
Comparison
Voltage/Current Handling
When you pick between MOSFETs and IGBTs, look at voltage and current. MOSFETs work best in circuits with low or medium voltage. These voltages are usually from tens to hundreds of volts. MOSFETs can handle a moderate amount of current. They also switch on and off very fast. IGBTs are better for jobs with high voltage and high current. You see IGBTs in things like motor drives and power inverters. Their design lets them move more current at higher voltages. This helps big systems work better and use less energy. IGBTs are used where you need strong performance and reliability.
| Aspect | IGBTs | MOSFETs |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Handling | High voltage (hundreds to thousands of volts) | Lower to medium voltage (tens to hundreds) |
| Current Handling | High current capability | Lower to moderate current capability |
| Efficiency | Lower conduction losses at high voltage/current | More efficient at low voltage/current |
| Switching Speed | Slower switching speed | Faster switching speed |
| Typical Applications | Motor drives, power inverters | Electronic switching circuits, voltage regulators |
If your project needs high voltage and current, IGBTs work better and are more reliable. If you need fast switching and low voltage, MOSFETs are the best choice.
Switching Frequency
Switching speed changes how your circuit works. MOSFETs can switch very fast, even at hundreds of kHz. This makes them great for power supplies and other high-frequency jobs. IGBTs switch slower, usually only up to tens of kHz. Their design makes them turn off slower. This means they are not good for very fast switching. Use MOSFETs for high-frequency jobs. Use IGBTs for lower frequency and high-power jobs.
| Device Type | Carrier Type | Turn-On Time (ns) | Turn-Off Time (ns) | Practical Switching Frequency Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MOSFET | Majority carrier | ~44 | ~48 | Hundreds of kHz |
| IGBT | Majority + minority | ~34 | ~250 | Tens of kHz |
Tip: Fast switching means less heat and better efficiency. MOSFETs are best for high-frequency circuits. IGBTs are good for slower, high-power switching.
Thermal Management
Heat can hurt these devices. You must keep them cool to make them last longer. MOSFETs lose more energy as heat when their on-resistance goes up with temperature. You need good heat sinks for MOSFETs, especially in motor control and power supply circuits. IGBTs make more heat in big jobs, so they often use water-cooled heatsinks. Their on-state voltage drop does not change much with temperature. This helps keep them efficient. Both types need good thermal design. IGBTs often need more advanced cooling in large systems.
Note: Always check your cooling system. Good thermal management helps your devices work longer and safer.
Cost
Cost is important when picking a power switch. MOSFETs usually cost more than IGBTs with the same voltage rating. This is because making MOSFETs is harder, especially SiC MOSFETs. IGBTs are cheaper for high voltage and high current jobs. As technology gets better, the price difference is getting smaller. But most of the time, MOSFETs still cost more.
| Device Type | Typical Cost (Similar Ratings) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| MOSFET | Higher | SiC MOSFETs cost even more |
| IGBT | Lower | Cost-effective for high-power systems |
If you want high performance for less money, IGBTs are smart for big jobs. For fast switching and low voltage, you may pay more for MOSFETs.
Quick Summary Table
| Feature | MOSFETs | IGBTs |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Range | Tens to hundreds of volts | Hundreds to thousands of volts |
| Current Range | Low to moderate | High |
| Switching Speed | Hundreds of kHz | Tens of kHz |
| Efficiency | High at low voltage | High at high voltage |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
Practical Selection Tips:
-
Pick MOSFETs for fast switching, low voltage, and moderate current.
-
Choose IGBTs for high voltage, high current, and when you need reliability and efficiency.
-
Always think about cooling and cost for your project.
Choosing the Right Power Switch
Selection Guide
When you pick a power switch, you must think about a few things. Every project is different and needs its own type of device. You should match the device to your voltage, current, and speed needs. Here is a table that shows the main differences:
| Factor | IGBTs | MOSFETs |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Range | Preferred for > 400 V | Preferred for < 250 V |
| Current Handling | Better for high current | Suitable for low to moderate current |
| Switching Speed | Slower, limited by tail current | Faster, better for high frequency switching |
| Efficiency | Lower switching losses at high power | Higher efficiency at low voltage/current |
| Thermal Management | Better thermal stability | Needs heat sinks, sensitive to temperature |
| Gate Drive Complexity | Simple voltage control | Simple voltage control |
| Ruggedness | Good overload and parallel capability | Lower short-circuit withstand capability |
| Application Examples | Motor drives, power inverters, induction heating | Power supplies, voltage regulators, high-frequency converters |
| Cost | Lower for high power | Higher, especially for advanced types |
Always check what voltage and current your system needs. If your project uses high voltage or high current, IGBTs are a better pick. If you want fast switching and lower voltage, MOSFETs work best. You also need to think about how efficient your device is and how much heat it will make. Some switches need more cooling than others. Cost is important too, especially if your project is big.
Tip: Try to balance voltage, current, speed, and cost. This helps you pick the best power switch for your job.
Motor Drive Control
Motor drive systems need the right power switch to work well. You want your motor to run smoothly and not waste energy. For big motors and heavy machines, IGBTs are used most often. They can handle lots of current and high voltage. You see IGBTs in factories and electric vehicles. They are strong and last a long time.
Here is a table that compares IGBTs and silicon carbide MOSFETs for motor control:
| Parameter | Si IGBT Characteristics | SiC MOSFET Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Range | 600V to 6500V, good for high voltage drives | 20V to 1000V, good for low to medium voltage |
| Switching Speed | Slower, best for lower frequency | Faster, best for high frequency |
| Conduction Losses | Higher, more heat | Lower, less heat |
| Switching Losses | Higher | Lower |
| Thermal Stability | Very good at high power | Good, but less than IGBT |
| Control Complexity | Simple gate drive | More complex gate drive |
Pick IGBTs for big motors and heavy machines. They keep your system safe and steady. If you want faster switching and better energy use, silicon carbide MOSFETs are a smart choice. These are good for things like electric cars. They help save space and need less cooling. You get better control and use less energy.
-
Use IGBTs for:
-
Industrial robots
-
Factory machines
-
Electric trains
-
-
Use silicon carbide MOSFETs for:
-
Electric cars
-
Compact inverters
-
High-speed automation
-
Note: When you design a motor drive, check voltage and current first. Then look at how fast you need to switch and how much heat your system can handle.
Other Applications
You also need to pick the right switch for power supplies, solar, and other systems. Switch-mode power supplies work at high speeds. This lets you use smaller parts and makes your system lighter. MOSFETs are a good choice for these jobs. They switch fast and waste less energy. This means less heat and better reliability.
Here are some things to think about for other uses:
-
Check the input voltage range. Your switch must handle changes in voltage.
-
Make sure the switch can handle the output voltage and current you need.
-
Look for high efficiency. This saves energy and money.
-
Think about how hot your system will get. Good cooling helps your switch last longer.
-
Pick a switch that fits your size and weight needs, especially for solar or wind.
-
Make sure your switch meets safety and noise rules. This helps avoid problems with other devices.
| Key Considerations | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Input Voltage Range | Handles different voltage levels in your system. |
| Output Needs | Must support your load safely. |
| Efficiency | Saves energy and money. |
| Operating Temperature | Works well in your environment. |
| Cooling | Keeps your device safe and long-lasting. |
| Size and Weight | Important for portable or compact designs. |
| Reliability | Reduces downtime and repairs. |
| Availability | Easy to find and replace. |
| EMC | Reduces noise and meets standards. |
| Switching Speed | Affects energy use and performance. |
Tip: For power supplies and renewable energy, always pick a switch that matches your voltage, current, and speed needs. This helps your system work better and last longer.
You can use these simple rules to pick the right power switch for many jobs. Always start by checking voltage and current. Then look at speed, efficiency, and cost. This way, you get the best device for your motor, power supply, or any other project.
Now you know how to pick between mosfet and igbt for your project. The table below shows their main differences. IGBT is great for handling lots of power. MOSFET works best with low or medium power. IGBT switches slower, but MOSFET can switch much faster. IGBT stays cool better, but MOSFET needs more cooling. IGBT usually costs less for big jobs. MOSFET can cost more, especially for new types.
Check out these resources to learn more. You can find technical guides and tutorials. There are also series about silicon, SiC, and GaN devices. Look for application notes and datasheets to help you.
FAQ
What happens if you use a MOSFET instead of an IGBT?
You may see lower voltage handling and less efficiency in high-power circuits. MOSFETs work best at low or medium voltage. If you use them in high-voltage jobs, they can overheat or fail.
Can you use IGBTs for high-frequency switching?
IGBTs switch slower than MOSFETs. You should not use them for high-frequency circuits. If you need fast switching, MOSFETs give you better results and less heat.
Why do MOSFETs need special gate drivers?
MOSFETs have high input capacitance. You need a strong gate driver to switch them quickly. A weak driver can slow down switching and cause more heat.
Which device is safer for beginners to use?
-
You may find MOSFETs easier to use.
-
They have simple control and fewer risks of latch-up.
-
Always protect the gate from static electricity.
Written by Jack Elliott from AIChipLink.
AIChipLink, one of the fastest-growing global independent electronic components distributors in the world, offers millions of products from thousands of manufacturers, and many of our in-stock parts is available to ship same day.
We mainly source and distribute integrated circuit (IC) products of brands such as Broadcom, Microchip, Texas Instruments, Infineon, NXP, Analog Devices, Qualcomm, Intel, etc., which are widely used in communication & network, telecom, industrial control, new energy and automotive electronics.
Empowered by AI, Linked to the Future. Get started on AIChipLink.com and submit your RFQ online today!
